Add a Break-Up Quarterback
A divorce specialist can play a key role on your planning team
By Le=
wis
Schiff
View Lewis's most recent musings in his blog
From the December
2007 Issue of Investment Advisor Magazine
In previous columns, we’ve examined how a variet=
y of
independent advisors—from solo practices to firms with offices in sev=
eral
cities—use outside specialists to provide the best service for client=
s.
While the management and selection of teams varies, flexibility and matching
client needs with the right expert are constant themes.
One of the most emotionally and financially challenging events for finan=
cial
advisors is the divorce of a client—or worse, the divorce of a couple
when you’ve worked closely with both parties. When analyzing the clie=
nt
situation in the stages before a divorce settlement, advisors have learned =
that
the division of assets is not a simple case of dividing everything by two. =
The
subtleties of financial settlement in divorce render it a specialty beyond =
what
most financial planners handle on a daily basis.
Getting the Details
Carol Ann Wilson is a CFP and a CFDP—Certified Financial Divorce
Practitioner—in Longmont=
,
Colorado, who has specializ=
ed in
this area for decades and is the founder of the Institute for Certified Div=
orce
Planners. She’s found over the years that even divorce attorneys need
help in understanding the financial side of divorce, such as using the tax =
code
to benefit their clients.
Wilson
recalls one case where an overlooked detail about the husband’s job <=
span
class=3DSpellE>perqs completely changed the attorney and client’s understanding of the case. The wife had
already moved to Colorado,
while the husband was back east as the CEO of a major corporation. As Wilson tried to as=
semble a
list of assets, the client’s attorney stated that he didn’t bel=
ieve
the husband’s corporation had a defined benefit plan. Wilson knew otherwise and requested tha=
t the
attorney ask the question directly and probe deeper. As it turned out, the
husband did have substantial assets through the plan. Since the attorney
hadn’t asked about the plan previously, the husband wasn’t
volunteering any additional information.
Wilson had
another case where an attorney with whom she had collaborated several times called about a $45 million case. The attorney sa=
id
that the husband was offering his client $8 million. “Don’t you
think that that’s enough? She doesn’t need more than that,̶=
1;
the attorney told her. Wilson<=
/st1:City>
told him that half would be a place to start negotiating and it wasn’t
just about need. It was about the couple’s history together and the
history of the accumulation and growth of their assets.
“Often, the husband is either the CEO or a top executive of a large
corporation, and is making anywhere from half to $1 million annually and th=
ey
have millions in assets,” Wilson
says.
“He’s usually the one that’s pretty tuned in to their
financial situation.”
When Wilson
shows wives graphs of their future finances, they often don’t underst=
and
why their net worths cannot go up the same as t=
heir
husbands. Wilson
explains that, after the divorce is final, the husband will continue earnin=
g a
great deal of money, which will increase his net worth. The wife will never
have that earning potential—unless she has her own career.
Defining True Value
Another problem Wilson
has seen is that couples think about dividing assets without recognizing th=
eir
true value. One wife even argued that she should take the retirement plan
rather than the cash account, which the husband had offered her. She wanted=
the
plan assets to make sure that she would have retirement income, she said. <=
st1:place
w:st=3D"on">Wilson explained t=
o her
that the retirement plan wasn’t worth as much as cash because of the
taxes due on withdrawal. She didn’t get it. She remained hooked on
wanting the retirement account. It took a lot of explaining, even to the
attorney, but then they understood that the wife’s solution wasn̵=
7;t
in her best interest.
Joyce Pearson is a CFP and a CDFA (Certified Divorce Financial Analyst) =
in Scottsdale, Arizona,
who specializes in working with clients going through divorce and working w=
ith
their other advisors through her firm, NetVEST
Financial LLC. She consults for couples in mediation through Equitable Divo=
rce
Solutions LLC. She says she started thinking about this specialty in 1990 w=
hen
a client who had just moved from Chicago
handed her a check for $800,000 to invest. The amount represented the proce=
eds
from selling a building in her divorce settlement. Pearson started
brainstorming about the various ways by which some additional dollars could
have come her client’s way rather than just a flat-out selling of the
asset followed by paying the taxes.
Financial Traps in Divorce
Financial planners who specialize in divorce cases focus on four major plan=
ning
issues:
1 | 2
| Next
page >
Add a Break-Up Quarterback
(page 2 of 2)
- “Equal” is
relative. As with the wife who wanted the retirement plan assets inste=
ad
of cash, clients and even other advisors don’t always understand=
the
true net value of assets, which aren’t always as obvious as this
example. The primary and vacation homes are other examples—both =
have
continuing financial obligations. A divorce specialist would provide an
in-depth analysis of whether such assets provide a good solution for t=
he
client’s particular circumstances.
- The story behind earnings
potential of the higher-income earner. If a wife supported her husband=
as
he worked on his MBA or stopped her career to raise the children, she =
may
be entitled to additional payments.
- How taxes affect settleme=
nt
amounts. That $2 million IRA brings taxes at the time withdrawals are
made. A divorce specialist would look carefully at the tax implication=
s of
selling homes or property as part of the settlement. It can also be a
negotiating tactic. Wilso=
n
notes that if a wife gets the primary house and even if she lives there
for four or five years, she’ll get her $250,000 exclusion—=
and
so can the husband. He needs to have lived in the house for at least t=
wo
years and stay on the deed as an owner so the IRS recognizes him. The
arrangement also needs to be part of the divorce decree.
- Depending on a spouse for
major financial support. Long-term financial dependency of one spouse =
on
the other may raise concerns. If the husband will depend on the wife f=
or
monthly payments, for example, he may need to secure his income stream
with a life insurance policy on her. The payment of the premiums would=
be
part of the settlement and the insurance expert on the team will need =
to
confirm premium payments. Before both parties reach a settlement, the =
team
should receive confirmation of insurance companies’ willingness =
to
underwrite the insured and then purchase a policy from a carrier.
For the same reason, the spouse making the payments needs long-term
disability coverage at the maximum insurable amount, which by law is still less than 70% of annual salary. A person is t=
en
times more likely to have a long-term disability during his or her work yea=
rs
than to die during that time.
“One of the biggest challenges I have in working with wives underg=
oing
a divorce is to help them understand that they may not be able to have the =
same
lifestyle that they were afforded before,” says Pearson.
“That’s where I spend time showing them the cash flow and the
numbers. Then, they come to that realization.” It’s emotional,
especially in a situation where they’re not voluntarily downgrading.<=
/p>
Pearson points out the emotional advantage held by the spouse asking for=
the
divorce. “Let’s say you’ve been married 15 or 20 years. O=
ne
day, your wife walks in and announces she wants a divorce. She wants it now.
The trick is she’s been thinking about it for quite a while—and=
it
has hit you over the head like a ton of bricks. You have to play catch-up.
Mentally, you have to get to the same mindset that your wife has.”
Typically, you go through several different phases: this will blow over;
she’ll come back to me; we’ll make it work; we’ll go to
counseling, etc. Then, when the realization hits that, no, this is serious,
comes the anger. “When we get past that, they’re ready to deal =
with
the financial issues and the reality,” observes Pearson. “During
that period of time, I’m showing them cash flow numbers, but also
realizing that many of them will not accept that until they’ve caught=
up
emotionally.”
Then, they’re ready to deal with the financial questions. She expl=
ains
the details so a spouse without a financial background can understand the
potential settlement agreement. For example, she’ll show a wife how h=
er
husband’s stock options work—and if she does accept a portion of
them as part of the settlement, what’s involved. Can they be transfer=
red?
What are the tax implications for her? What growth can she anticipate? What=
is the
downfall of accepting? If she doesn’t accept them, what will be a
potential offset for them?
Divorce specialist also run scenarios of different settlements. If a spo=
use
accepts a particular settlement offer, how will it look five or ten years
later? What will be the cash flow?
“I’ve always said that there are three divorces going on
here,” say Pearson. “There’s an emotional divorce,
there’s a legal divorce, and then there’s a financial
divorce.”
Lewis Schiff is the principal of Advanced Planning Group, a family
office network for advisors. His forthcoming book, The Middle-Class
Millionaire, will be published in January 2008. He can be reached at lewisschiff@advancedplanni=
ng.org.
<
Previous page 1
| 2 |
Article Menu
Email
this Article Print
this Article
About Us Privacy Policy S=
ite Map
=
Reprints
Advertising Information RSS Fee=
------=_NextPart_01C876D9.1D1C3DB0
Content-Location: file:///C:/D15290CB/AddaBreak-UpQuarterback_files/image001.jpg
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Type: image/jpeg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------=_NextPart_01C876D9.1D1C3DB0
Content-Location: file:///C:/D15290CB/AddaBreak-UpQuarterback_files/filelist.xml
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Content-Type: text/xml; charset="utf-8"